ANALOGUE OF THE ABRAHAM–MINKOWSKI CONTROVERSY IN ELECTRONIC OPTICS

In the problem of electron diffraction by a standing light wave (the Kapitza–Dirac effect), an electronic refractive index can be defined as the ratio of electron momenta in the wave field and outside it. Moreover, both kinetic and canonical electron momenta can be used for this purpose, which corresponds to the Abraham–Minkowski controversy in photonic optics. It is shown that in both cases the same expression for the electronic refractive index is obtained. This is consistent with Barnett's resolution of the Abraham–Minkowski dilemma.